Psalms commentary
Sunday, September 21st, 2008 11:38 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
I previously posted this in
weirdjews3_14 but didn't get get much response, so am crossposting it too here.
Every Shabbos I go to shul and they read a portion from the Torah service—and (except when I'm leyning, being gabbai or standing sgan) I totally ignore what's being read, and read the English and commentary instead. For many years that meant the Hertz or Cohen Soncino chumashim, until I got really rather familiar with in particular the former of these. Then I encountered the Etz Chayim chumash, and read that when I could get hold of it for two or three years.
Last year as Simchas Torah came round, I took down the copy of The Living Torah I'd been given as a cheder prize, and never done more than dipped into; and have this last year been reading it, one sedra at a time, cover to cover.
This year it occurred to me I might do something radical, and (shock! horror!) read something other than the weekly Torah portion, as (a) there's plenty else I'm not so knowledgeable on, and (b) it would mean I could come back to the Torah fresh next year. I thought it might be an idea to read a commentary on the Book of Psalms,* as we read so many of them in the service, and I scarcely know more about them than what's in the text itself. So I thought of the Soncino edition, as, if it's anything like the Cohen chumash, it'll be a trustworthy redaction of traditional Jewish commentaries (i.e. not suffering (or not anywhere near so blatantly) from the, ah, blinkeredness of the commentary in the Artscroll siddur).
But I thought I'd post my idea here before I bought the book blind, in case anyone has any recommendations of other Psalms commentaries.
* I also thought of reading the copy of The Book of Our Heritage I was given by my Barmitzvah teacher cover to cover, but I can do that in parallel.
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-community.gif)
Every Shabbos I go to shul and they read a portion from the Torah service—and (except when I'm leyning, being gabbai or standing sgan) I totally ignore what's being read, and read the English and commentary instead. For many years that meant the Hertz or Cohen Soncino chumashim, until I got really rather familiar with in particular the former of these. Then I encountered the Etz Chayim chumash, and read that when I could get hold of it for two or three years.
Last year as Simchas Torah came round, I took down the copy of The Living Torah I'd been given as a cheder prize, and never done more than dipped into; and have this last year been reading it, one sedra at a time, cover to cover.
This year it occurred to me I might do something radical, and (shock! horror!) read something other than the weekly Torah portion, as (a) there's plenty else I'm not so knowledgeable on, and (b) it would mean I could come back to the Torah fresh next year. I thought it might be an idea to read a commentary on the Book of Psalms,* as we read so many of them in the service, and I scarcely know more about them than what's in the text itself. So I thought of the Soncino edition, as, if it's anything like the Cohen chumash, it'll be a trustworthy redaction of traditional Jewish commentaries (i.e. not suffering (or not anywhere near so blatantly) from the, ah, blinkeredness of the commentary in the Artscroll siddur).
But I thought I'd post my idea here before I bought the book blind, in case anyone has any recommendations of other Psalms commentaries.
* I also thought of reading the copy of The Book of Our Heritage I was given by my Barmitzvah teacher cover to cover, but I can do that in parallel.
no subject
Date: 2008-09-21 12:20 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2008-09-21 12:24 pm (UTC)